Kelvin on Fourier
One of my Friday lunch companions is reading a biography of Lord Kelvin (William Thomson), and mentioned that he had published a couple of papers on Fourier's work when he was 16. As most of you know, I enjoy tracking down and reading historic papers. It took a bit of work to find them because the Cambridge Mathematical Journal was reprinted in a new collection that changed the volume and page numbers.
Here are the two papers at archive.org:
* I also have to wonder if they saw that Fourier's work was starting down the path of showing that Newton's Calculus was not on a firm theoretical foundation. Rodgers and Boman's "How We Got From There To Here: A Story of Real Analysis" has a section titled "Joseph Fourier: The Man Who Broke Calculus." It's a free download at:
https://knightscholar.geneseo.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1019&context=oer-ost
Kelvin published them under the pseudonym "P.Q.R." According to Wikipedia, Fourier's results had been attacked by the established British math community largely because he was French; Kelvin had made the decision to study and defend "continental mathematics." *
Here are the two papers at archive.org:
- P.Q.R. "On Fourier's expansions of functions in trigonometric series". Cambridge Mathematical Journal. Vol 2: 258–262. (1841). https://archive.org/details/sim_cambridge-and-dublin-mathematical-journal_1841-05_2_12/page/258/mode/2up
- P.Q.R. "Note on a passage in Fourier's 'Heat'". Cambridge Mathematical Journal. Vol 3: 25–27. (1841). https://archive.org/details/sim_cambridge-and-dublin-mathematical-journal_1841-11_3_13/page/24/mode/2up
* I also have to wonder if they saw that Fourier's work was starting down the path of showing that Newton's Calculus was not on a firm theoretical foundation. Rodgers and Boman's "How We Got From There To Here: A Story of Real Analysis" has a section titled "Joseph Fourier: The Man Who Broke Calculus." It's a free download at:
https://knightscholar.geneseo.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1019&context=oer-ost
Highly recommended reading -- be sure to have a pencil and paper handy.
Comments